Home› Welcome to the FamilySearch Community!› Ask a Question› Family Tree

Merge warnings

System
System admin
October 12, 2023 edited September 26, 2024 in Family Tree
This discussion was created from comments split from: Is there a FS Report on how many duplicates have been merged by an individual?.
0

Comments

  • ColinCameron
    ColinCameron ✭✭✭
    October 11, 2023

    Wouldn’t it be great if it could tell some people which ones shouldn’t be merged? 😀

    0
  • Ottley BQ
    Ottley BQ ✭✭✭
    October 11, 2023

    @ColinCameron there's always the option to add an Alert Note; add one to the two (or more) profiles and explain why they shouldn't be merged. That, of course, is no guarantee that it won't happen.... 😶

    0
  • ColinCameron
    ColinCameron ✭✭✭
    October 12, 2023
    https://community.familysearch.org/en/discussion/comment/530086#Comment_530086

    Ah, but to do that you would have to know, in advance, that someone was likely to merge John Smith who died in England in 1810, with Fred Bloggs who was born in America in 1895. Apparently because they both had a wife named Jane (the only similarity).

    0
  • Paul W
    Paul W ✭✭✭✭✭
    October 12, 2023 edited October 12, 2023

    @ColinCameron

    Yes, I do make that kind of assumption! I am currently working to establish which records to connect to three individuals named John Harrison - all born at Loughborough, Leicestershire around 1833. I have added Alert Notes in their Collaboration sections to highlight what I have currently discovered about them and to not confuse one with the other, etc. When I add a note (headed, say, "Identity of John Harrison ....") I always add the ID reference after the name. That way, I have easily found (unless my notes have been deleted!) my original comments against each profile, even if another user has chosen to still go ahead and merge these different individuals.

    In summary, I would always assume it is likely such persons are going to be merged by a careless / inexperienced user, so always place them on my Following list, too!

    2
  • ColinCameron
    ColinCameron ✭✭✭
    October 12, 2023

    Hi @Paul W

    There’s a big difference between merging people with the same name, living in the same area, around the same time, you can anticipate that, and merging people with different names, who lived in different centuries, on different continents.

    0
  • Paul W
    Paul W ✭✭✭✭✭
    October 13, 2023 edited October 13, 2023

    @ColinCameron

    During the "average week" I encounter both examples, as you can imagine. Whilst there might be "more of an excuse" for the former behaviour, this does not make this type of merge less damaging. In fact, it is far more difficult to discover errors in these instances. So, a merge involving individuals like your John Smith and Fred Bloggs is usually quite easy to spot / sort out. However, in my example of the three John Harrison individuals, who would be able to readily identify a careless user had believed them to be one and the same individual - and / or added wrong parents / spouses / children, with or without merging them?

    Silly to argue over the issue, when I'm sure we both agree that making a situation clear is one matter, but getting a careless / indifferent user not to make a merge, if they are really determined to do so, is quite another.

    Just as a matter of interest - if you, or anyone has the time: would you merge GM1D-CFF with LKQF-9JW, I wonder? Look at the names (especially of parents) and you'll find this falls somewhat between the two examples we are talking about! I think it illustrates the care we must exercise whatever the situation - that's why I haven't made an attempt to merge, as yet.

    1
This discussion has been closed.
Clear
No Groups Found

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 42.7K Ask a Question
  • 3.3K General Questions
  • 570 FamilySearch Center
  • 6.7K Get Involved/Indexing
  • 640 FamilySearch Account
  • 6.5K Family Tree
  • 5.1K Search
  • 997 Memories
  • 2 Suggest an Idea
  • 473 Other Languages
  • 62 Community News
  • Groups