Home› Welcome to the FamilySearch Community!› Suggest an Idea

Wrong Place Names on Index Records and Two Datasets for each Village

fredheld1
fredheld1 ✭
May 27, 2022 in Suggest an Idea

I found a number of indexed entries that are identified with the wrong village in the FamilySearch Search German database. In investigating this problem another more major problem was discovered.

Please be aware there are two different villages named Bieringen in the Kingdom of Wuerttemberg: Bieringen (OA. K�nzelsau) is about 43 miles NNE of Stuttgart on the Jagst River in Jagstkreis and Bieringen (OA. Horb) is about 26 miles SW of Stuttgart on the Neckar River in Schwarzwaldkreis.

Go to the Catalog entry for Bieringen (OA. K�nzelsau) - https://www.familysearch.org/search/catalog/66760 . Copy the number for the first Microfilm - 878230. Go to FamilySearch Search and enter the microfilm number into the "Image Group Number (DGS) or Microfilm Number" field. Doing a search with no search name results with 18,467 hits in the dataset. Notice that although this microfilm is for the village of Bieringen (OA. K�nzelsau) many of the entries are incorrectly marked as Bieringen (OA. Horb). Now capture the DGS number for the same microfilm - 8109461 and do the same exercise. Now there are 36,860 hits and the same is true of many of the records with the wrong village name. Checking specific entries between the two searches show that in one dataset the village name is wrong and for the same entry in the other the village name is correct. Conclusion: there are two different datasets for the same microfilm.

  • Why are there a two different datasets for the same microfilm?
  • Some of the village names are wrong.

Go through the same exercise for the other microfilms in this village set and the same issues exist.

Mic# 878230/ DGS 8109461 - 18,467 vs 36,860 hits and many wrong village names

Mic# 878231/ DGS 8643236 - 5,853 vs 11,767 his and many wrong village names

Mic# 878232/ DGS 8643237 - 0 vs 7,800 hits and many wrong village names

For the village of Bieringen (OA. Horb):

Mic# 958265/ DGS 8114339 - 3,384 vs 9,677 hits (village name appears correct)

Mic# 958266/ DGS 8655466 - 5,900 vs 5,982 hits

Mic# 958267/ DGS 8655537 - 2,064 vs 6,231 hits

Mic# 958268/ DGS 8550523 - 0 vs 577 hits

HOW MANY OTHER DATASETS ARE LIKE THIS???????

Tagged:
  • New
1
1
Up Down
1 votes

New · Last Updated May 27, 2022

Clear
No Groups Found

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 27.4K FamilySearch Help
  • 142 Get Involved
  • 2.9K General Questions
  • 473 FamilySearch Center
  • 515 FamilySearch Account
  • 5.1K Family Tree
  • 3.9K Search
  • 5.1K Indexing
  • 725 Memories
  • 374 Other Languages
  • 36 Community News
  • 7.2K Suggest an Idea
  • Groups