Sourcing DNA studies and confidentiality?
I have been involved with a DNA study which resulted in some major changes to a distant ancestors relationships. The study was published in a Histoire Quebec, which is a paid journal. Is sourcing the Journal the best way to source the data? What is the Family search view on DNA research and it's implications on long established family trees.
Answers
-
I can't speak to FS's stances or policies (on DNA or anything else), but I believe it is perfectly fine to cite a paid journal. It is exactly analogous to citing a published book: most people would need to buy or borrow the book to verify the citation, but this doesn't make the citation any less valid.
0 -
Hello @NicholasLaBelle,
Here is something I found in an article from the Help Center on DNA:
DNA testing does not replace traditional forms of family history research. Rather, it can complement a well-documented family tree.
Please note that FamilySearch does not endorse or recommend any commercial DNA applications for genetic genealogy. Nor does our Family Tree provide specific features to post or link DNA groups based on DNA matches.
There are other articles in there as well. I searched just with "DNA".
Best Wishes!
0 -
Nicholas
Welcome to the "Community.FamilySearch" Forum.
I am just another 'lowly' User/Patron ...
Just in passing ...
Your Question: Is sourcing the Journal the best way to source the data?
Short Answer: 'Yes', if that is what you have.
Your Question: What is the Family search view on DNA research & it's implications on long established family trees.
Short Answer(s): (1) Please read all of the following Articles; and, (2) That is a very good question ...
'FamilySearch', currently, DOES NOT, have the capabilities to record DNA.
[ We can but live in hope ... ]
As far as I am aware, there are OTHER 'On-Line' Websites, with such capabilities.
And ...
Here is a "Knowledge Article" in 'FamilySearch':
Using DNA in family history research
https://www.familysearch.org/en/help/helpcenter/article/using-dna-in-family-history-research
Where it states, among other things:
Quote:
------------------
Please note that FamilySearch does not endorse or recommend any commercial DNA applications for genetic genealogy.
Nor does our Family Tree provide specific features to post or link DNA groups based on DNA matches.
------------------
But ...
That Said ...
'FamilySearch' does suggest, that DNA Testing, DOES NOT replace traditional forms of Genealogical/Family History research; BUT, rather, that DNA Testing CAN complement a well-documented "Family Tree".
And ...
Certainly NOT forgotten ...
'FamilySearch' provides information and recourses to help navigate DNA in Genealogical/Family History research.
Here are just some of the resources:
==================
'FamilySearch' "Blog":
=================
What Is DNA?—A Molecule That Links Generations
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/what-is-dna
Using DNA to Discover Your Deep Ancestry
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/using-dna-to-discover-your-deep-ancestry
Overcoming Brick Walls in Your Family Tree with a Genealogy DNA Test
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/genealogy-dna-test
How DNA Testing Can Help Your Family History
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/how-dna-testing-can-help-your-family-history
Connecting with Your Biological Family through DNA Testing
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/how-to-find-birth-parents-through-dna
DNA Cousin Matches Can Lead to Family History Discoveries
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/dna-match
DNA Testing at Family Reunions
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/dna-testing-at-family-reunions
DNA 101: Back to the Basics
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/dna-101-back-to-the-basics
Creating a DNA Testing Plan
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/creating-a-dna-testing-plan
Untangling the Centimorgans on Your DNA Test
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/centimorgan-chart-understanding-dna
Resources for the DNA Enthusiast
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/resources-for-the-dna-enthusiast
Healing and Family History: The Emotional Side of DNA
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/healing-and-family-history-the-emotional-side-of-dna
Advancing Your Genealogy Research with DNA: Part 1
And, a couple of 'Oldies' ...
Has My Family's DNA Been Tested?
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/has-my-familys-dna-been-tested
Can Your Genes Tell Your Family Story?
https://www.familysearch.org/en/blog/can-your-genes-tell-your-family-story
=====================
'FamilySearch' "Lessons"
====================
DNA: An Introduction to Genetic Genealogy
[ x6 Lessons ]
▬ 1. Introduction
▬ 2. What is DNA?
▬ 3. Why is DNA Valuable?
▬ 4. Types of DNA
▬ 5. DNA and Genealogy
▬ 6. Testing Companies
DNA: I've Tested, Now What?
[ x6 Lessons ]
▬ 1. Introduction
https://www.familysearch.org/en/help/helpcenter/lessons/dna-ive-tested-now-what-introduction
▬ 2. First Steps
https://www.familysearch.org/en/help/helpcenter/lessons/dna-ive-tested-now-what-first-steps
▬ 3. Cousin Matches
https://www.familysearch.org/en/help/helpcenter/lessons/dna-ive-tested-now-what-cousin-matches
▬ 4. Match Clusters
https://www.familysearch.org/en/help/helpcenter/lessons/dna-ive-tested-now-what-match-clusters
▬ 5. DNA First Approach
https://www.familysearch.org/en/help/helpcenter/lessons/dna-ive-tested-now-what-dna-first-approach
▬ 6. Research First Approach
How Genealogists Use DNA
https://www.familysearch.org/en/help/helpcenter/lessons/how-genealogists-use-dna
============================
This "Community.FamilySearch" Forum
'Groups'
===========================
Home > Groups > Genetic Genealogy Research
Genetic Genealogy Research
Description: Research questions and sharing of best practices related to genetic genealogy
https://community.familysearch.org/en/group/85-genetic-genealogy-research
Home > Groups > Genealogy and the Y Chromosome
Genealogy and the Y Chromosome
Description:
Y-DNA has become one of the most important items in the genealogist's toolkit. Unlike the other DNA types, it's prefect for surname studies. It's true that only men can test, but women can test male relatives. Join and learn the methodology.
https://community.familysearch.org/en/group/83-genealogy-and-the-y-chromosome
Home > Groups > Kendall One-Name Study & DNA Project
Kendall One-Name Study & DNA Project
Description:
The Kendall One-Name Study is a group of genealogists, family historians and hobbyists collaborating and sharing information on the Kendall surname.
https://community.familysearch.org/en/group/112-kendall-one-name-study-dna-project 4
Now ...
After ALL That ...
Just saying ...
NOT included ...
But, NOT forgotten ...
I hope, that some of this may help/assist, somewhat
Brett
0 -
Even though several people here have stated that DNA testing does not replace traditional forms of genealogy, that is certainly incorrect in some instances. Thomas Jefferson left no traditional genealogical trace of his liaison with Sally Hemmings, and Sally's descendants were never proved to be Thomas Jefferson descendants - until they were proved by DNA. All that existed was oral tradition. So, when @NicholasLaBelle says a DNA study has altered some previously established family trees, that DNA study is an authoritative source. What she is asking is what format to use as a source.
0 -
Gail
It's 'Brett'.
Just in passing ...
And ...
In 'Answer', to him INITIAL 'Question', of: "... Is sourcing the Journal the best way to source the data? ..." ...
I have, ALREADY responded, in my previous 'Comment', by suggesting: "... 'Yes', if that is what you have. ..." ...
[ And, that was towards, the "Start" of my 'Comment' ... ]
So ...
That Said ...
Question: WHAT more needs to be Said, in that respect?
Just curious.
Brett
1 -
LOL. "That Said ... What more needs to be said"
I like it.
But the below is what I was referring to. The truth is, DNA can change a well documented Family Tree, even when there is no traditional forms of sources to back up the change.
But ...
That Said ...
'FamilySearch' does suggest, that DNA Testing, DOES NOT replace traditional forms of Genealogical/Family History research; BUT, rather, that DNA Testing CAN complement a well-documented "Family Tree".
0 -
Just note I am Male. I know my username is a little smooshed so it may not have been obvious. Regardless all of these answers have been helpful. I sent this question when I was struggling to not get my ancestors relationships deleted. The deletions of sourced changes has stopped. I imagine that anytime some view which is controversial is found true there will be people who will vehemently disagree. The negatives of an open platform are that there are always going to be the people who abuse the system.
2 -
@NicholasLaBelle I'm so sorry! Noted! I guess there are nagatives of an open platform, but quite honestly, I love working in FamilySearch as a compliment to my trees in Ancestry. I keep my wide, greater family in order here, perhaps a little more than Ancestry. But I work both in tandem and in FamilySearch have all the ancestor family friends / acquaintances records filled with information or memories I know about them. I cannot do that in Ancestry!
1
