Home› Ask a Question› Family Tree

Why can't a "Dismiss" option be added to 'Male or Female is Required" ?

ScottStieg
ScottStieg ✭✭
November 2 in Family Tree

This shows as a 'Data Problem', but, quite often, the sex is unavailable and never will be, as with a stillborn infant. It just was never recorded. This seems dismissible then, as with any other data problem than cannot be rationalized. Also, if there's an "Unknown " option why does selecting this not 'solve' the problem?

2

Answers

  • Lydiagrace01
    Lydiagrace01 ✭✭
    November 3 edited November 4

    @ScottStieg

    For data problems, if the issue can be dismissed, a Dismiss button will appear. If the record contains an error, correct it; if it does not, you might be able to dismiss the data problem.

    "Male or Female Is Required" cannot be dismissed.

    If you need to indicate unknown sex, enter the sex if known; otherwise, please do as much research as you can to identify the sex.

    -4
  • AnneLoForteWillson
    AnneLoForteWillson mod
    November 4

    @ScottStieg Interesting that the unknown sex is not dismissible. Seems like a good idea to me. I'd recommend that you send your idea to the Suggest an Idea form. Those ideas are forwarded to the engineers and product teams that are building and fixing FamilySearch. You might find that your suggestion appears in a future update.

    1
  • Jenny.B
    Jenny.B ✭✭✭
    November 5

    All
    Understand the poster's points of view; but, would humbly suggest that as this Website is maintained by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saint and is principally utitlised for Temple Work by Members of the Church; then, that is why the Gender of Male or Female is Required and cannot be Dismissed, as per the original design.
    Not saying that when Unknown is selected that the Data Problem should not be able to be Dismissed.
    Just saying that as Gender is Required for Temple Work, that the original design would not allow dismissal.
    If Unknown is selected; then, Temple Work will not proceed.
    Anyway, Temple Work is not required for Stillborn children.
    But, I suppose, in those Countries, where an Infant actually Lived for a short period; but, was recorded as Stillborn; and, the Gender was not recorded; then, that would cause issues.
    Suppose, that in such cases that an Infant could be recorded twice, once as Male and once as Female and the Temple Work done for both.
    Not clean for genealogical purposes; but, workable for Temple Work and Members of the Church.
    So yes, agree that when Unknown is selected for Gender, the Data Problem should be able to be Dismissed.
    Just some thoughts.

    0
  • Adrian Bruce1
    Adrian Bruce1 ✭✭✭✭✭
    November 6

    If

    this Website is maintained by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saint and is principally utitlised for Temple Work by Members of the Church;

    then a lot of us will leave.

    Generally, I have to say that FS does a good job in hiding the implications of the religious angle from us non-LDS genealogists. So much so that if there are two ways to remove some disastrous data from the tree, I will always try the approach that has less impact on ordinance etc data - always assuming that I can remember the excellent comments made by some of those genealogists who are Church members.

    However, there are limits

    4
  • maryellenstevensbarnes1
    maryellenstevensbarnes1 ✭✭✭✭✭
    November 7

    Copied from Google according to AI:

    FamilySearch.org is a free, international public genealogical resource sponsored by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

    Purpose

    • Free Ancestor Discovery: To help people around the world discover, gather, and connect their family stories, heritage, and ancestors free of charge—regardless of race, culture, tradition, or religious affiliation.
    • Record Preservation: To actively gather, digitize, index, and preserve historical genealogical and vital records (such as birth, marriage, death, census, and probate records) globally.
    • Collaborative World Tree: To maintain a single, massive collaborative online family tree (FamilySearch Family Tree) where users contribute data and build shared genealogical lines together.
    • Latter-day Saint Ordinances: For members of the sponsoring church, it also facilitates sacred family history research to perform religious temple ordinances for deceased ancestors.

    Vision

    • Connecting Families: "To enable inspiring journeys that bring joy to all people as they discover, gather, and connect their family—past, present, and future", guided by principles of inspiration, trust, kindness, effectiveness, and simplicity.

    This is from my personal thoughts: most LDS Church members of whom I am one, have no desire to force their/our religious beliefs or convictions on anyone, living or dead. We, like you, are interested in family history and genealogy for their own merits and for the impact of history and genealogy on the world as we see it.

    2
  • Tomlinsonkl
    Tomlinsonkl mod
    November 7

    Thank you @maryellenstevensbarnes1 your thoughts are spot on.

    2
  • betsy123
    betsy123 mod
    November 8

    @maryellenstevensbarnes1 Thank you so much. Your explanation of FamilySearch's vision and purpose beautifully captures the ideals and values of so many who are dedicated to connecting their families across generations.

    1
  • David Alan Webber
    David Alan Webber ✭✭✭
    November 8

    To veer the discussion a little, I thought that I had seen an "unknown" option in the past, but perhaps only in certain areas of work.

    I can certainly agree with not wanting to misidentify someone, although, going back to Latter-day Saint teachings, in the millennium, mistakes will be corrected, as we'll have more access to knowledge where we don't now.

    For the topic at hand, I guess if we don't have a 3rd option, we do the best we can?

    1
  • CMichael7
    CMichael7 ✭✭
    November 8

    https://community.familysearch.org/en/discussion/comment/640583#Comment_640583

    There is an Unknown choice when editing records (the data associated with an image). It's important for names that could be either male or female in early censuses that didn't include gender.

    3
  • MandyShaw1
    MandyShaw1 ✭✭✭✭✭
    November 8 edited November 8

    'Find' for Family Tree and 'Search' for Historical Records both allow the user to filter on Sex and to choose '?' or 'Unspecified' respectively. I have used the latter successfully several times. The absence of a M/F value appears to me to be fully supported by FamilySearch, with the sole exception of DQS' lack of a Dismiss option as reported in this thread.

    @ScottStieg I would honestly suggest you post on the Data Quality Score Feedback Group about this issue (rather than Suggesting an Idea), my experience is that it's a very active and productive Group where the engineers contribute direct.

    2
  • ScottStieg
    ScottStieg ✭✭
    November 13

    Hi Everyone: Thanks for all the great comments! I had imagined gender and sex might be an LDS church issue, but totally agree that the LDS does a great job of rationalizing its beliefs and ordinance work with the realities of genealogy. (witness the addition of the **** marriage feature, albeit with warning!). FS would not be so popular if it didn't. By the above discussion, it seems as though selecting the option 'Unknown' or 'Not Recorded' or whatever you want to call it would take care of any 'Data Problem'. Apparently, then, there is no ordinance work possible on that person anyway. It's certainly not the same as refusing to identify yourself (living) as male or female. That latter issue is a whole other kettle of fish best reserved for private beliefs.

    However, that the 'Data Problem' warning appears , although interesting, has absolutely no consequence to my work. It does still seem odd to me that this one thing cannot be dismissed if there is no 'hope' of determining the sex of a person (as in Stillborn). 'Unknown' certainly leaves open the 'hope' or possibility of a new source showing up that does record the sex, and I've seen it happen. So, I don't think I will pursue this any further; all your comments put this one to bed for me; thanks!

    1
Clear
No Groups Found

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 48K Ask a Question
  • 7.7K Family Tree
  • 6.3K Search
  • 5.6K General Questions
  • 7K Get Involved
  • 1.2K Memories
  • 345 Other Languages
  • 84 Community News
  • Groups