Home› Ask a Question› Search

Are there guidelines to resolving brick walls?

chormy1
chormy1 ✭
May 19, 2023 edited July 26, 2024 in Search

I and others have been trying to locate the father of James William Smith, for decades. No one, including professionals, can locate his parents. There are speculations on numerous trees, of who the parents are, but there is no documentation. If I can be guided in the right direction, to hopefully resolve this brick wall, I'd really appreciate the assistance. Thank you. Debra Russ

0

Answers

  • No one in particular
    No one in particular ✭✭✭
    May 20, 2023 edited May 20, 2023

    You have my sympathy. Common surnames can be super brutal.

    I've beaten past a few brickwalls but yours seems a whole other level past anything I've done.

    All I can suggest is posting James' PID. A number of folks here have developed differing expertise. Maybe one of us knows something uniquely helpful.

    0
  • ColinCameron
    ColinCameron ✭✭✭
    May 20, 2023

    A location and a time period would be the minimum needed to make an even remotely helpful suggestion.

    2
  • chormy1
    chormy1 ✭
    May 21, 2023

    PID is LHTN-HS5. Thank you all, for your responses. Finding the father of James William Smith, seems pretty much hopeless. Some have speculated this is an NPE. One particular website, has my autosomal DNA matching with James and his descendants, but other Smiths show as no blood relationship. As I mentioned, many ancestry trees have parents listed, but the William Smith, doesn't add up, as the father of James. The Burge mother for James, could be potentially correct, but there's no documentation of his father. A Y-DNA test would be most helpful, but I have no one to ask, so far. Thanks again.

    0
This discussion has been closed.
Clear
No Groups Found

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 44.8K Ask a Question
  • 3.6K General Questions
  • 599 FamilySearch Center
  • 6.9K Get Involved
  • 678 FamilySearch Account
  • 7K Family Tree
  • 5.5K Search
  • 1.1K Memories
  • 505 Other Languages
  • 66 Community News
  • Groups