홈› 그룹› Data Quality Score Feedback

Data Quality Score Feedback

가입

Source quality rated as "medium"...Really?

sc woz
sc woz mod
March 30 March 30 편집 안 Social Groups

@rosemama This was moved to Data Quality Score Feedback so the experts can weigh in.

This entry for Nathan Powers is rated as "medium". It has no sources, no family members, no "memories" or comments. The only information given is the name & birth/death dates. This is just poor genealogical work, and to give it a score of "medium" enables the lazy.

Nathan Powers (1750–1773) • Person • Family Tree

image.png

0

의견

  • FrankLittle
    FrankLittle ✭✭✭
    March 30 March 30 편집

    It's been merged so difficult to see, but there was a baptism entered apparently when this person was first added in 2012, so there is evidence of a person; whether that is enough for a Medium score I don't know.

    Of greater concern is the merge which is of two different persons both of whom originally entered because of a baptism. Given the generation-sized gap between these two baptisms, it is not obvious they are the same person at all. (The only time I can imagine that is if one is actually a birth not a baptism; a Friends birth and a later baptism for marriage purposes can do that, certainly in England.)

    I suppose in any case the merge will have to be undone.

    0
  • Rhonda Budvarson
    Rhonda Budvarson ✭✭✭✭
    April 6

    @rosemama thank you for the information. I will ask for someone to take a look at this.

    0
  • Mary Anna Ebert
    Mary Anna Ebert ✭✭✭
    April 8

    @rosemama Thanks for your feedback!

    The Quality Score is still a work in progress, and the rules are evolving. I will take a look at your case and see if there are some changes we can make.

    Thank you!

    0
Clear
No Groups Found

범주

  • 모든 카테고리