No Indexed Sources
Marie Geneviève Harnois GZZV-CD3 has three excellent sources from French Canadian Catholic church records and yet she has a score of "0" for Consistent with Sources because she has no indexed sources. She has indexed sources, but they were not indexed by FamilySearch. That should not make a difference. Someone did correct research and found her baptism, marriage and burial in parish records. Those are excellent sources.
의견
-
Whilst sources not from FamilySearch are not particularly helpful to those who don't have a subscription to the website where they are to be found, I found that reason of: "This person has no indexed sources" to be rather silly. So, I could even have a dozen FamilySearch image-only sources attached (confirming all the Vitals details) and that, apparently, would still give a zero star rating to "Consistent with Sources"? No, the criteria for determining the PQS rating for this category certainly needs to be reassessed.
1 -
I imagine the issue here is the PQS algorithm getting sufficient access to assess the quality of the source/index (e.g. an Ancestry Family Tree source wouldn't, hopefully, produce any points). In an ideal world the PQS thinking would be a standard across providers.
0 -
@MABeldin thank you for your feedback. A ticket has been created. And this issue is under review by the engineers.
2
