Merge faulty inconsistency messages
Answers
-
Unfortunately you completed the merge before letting anyone analyze this for you. I don't want to undo the merge. Also, you image doesn't include the other set of parents for Juila which is what is being compared to give these messages.
However, looking at the Change Log, I can speculate some. After you completed the merge, another user did come along and delete a set of parents for Julia:
Julia Helen, prior to any merges, had as her father Frank Lenhart. Julia, before being deleted, had as her father Stanley Alexander Goralewski. Just as the merge routined warned you, these two father's first names are very different and their last names are very different.
As far as mothers, the original two mothers for these two women were Barbara Stein born in 1887 and Barbra Elizabeth Lenhardt born in 1911 these are over 24 years apart so again the merge routine is correct in pointing out a major concern. Regarding the warning about birth place, I'm not sure because I can't tell exactly the time when changes were made, but I assume that at the time of the merge one of then had Hungary as her birthplace and the other had Yugoslavia.
These warnings should have enough for you to back off from the merge and figure out why these two Julia's had such different information and resolved that, with good sources and reason statements before merging them.
Also, looking at the reason entered for the merge, it also has some problems. It states: First and last names match. Parents match. Spouse matches. Children match. However, the parents did not match and only one of them had children.
I would suggest you restore the Julia that was deleted and put her back with her original parents, then try to figure out if these really were the same people. It does look like they were both connected to the same husband, but that could be where the error began. Maybe the daughter of Stanley was incorrectly given that husband.
4 -
Julia Lenhardt born in 1909
Was removed from parents Barbara Elizabeth Lenhardt born in 1911 [also listed as sister and only 2 years younger] and Stanley Alexander Goralewski born 1903 [also listed as brother in law only 6 years older]
0

