Incorrect classification of entry
The following is one of a recent spate of incorrectly classified/indexed records I have encountered:
"England Deaths and Burials, 1538-1991", ,
FamilySearch
(https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:J8R5-293 : Thu Jul 18 15:52:43 UTC 2024), Entry for Ellenor Pratt and John Pratt, 1 Dec 1713.
The record clearly states that the death place/burial was
Chester Le Street, Durham, England
yet in 'find' it has been grouped under United States or America, West Virginia, Mononongalia. I know that this is partly a historical problem, but any chance that some more effort is directed to cleansing the database, geography wise, rather than on redesigning the look of family trees?
Answers
-
Without seeing your search results, I would have to guess this is what we've been calling "on-the-fly" results. When I searched for a death for Ellenor Pratt, my search results correctly showed Durham, England as the place.
2 -
I can't make it go wrong for either Ellenor (the principal here) or her father (who is presumably mentioned on the record).
However, I suspect I might know why it's gone pear-shaped.
According to the record detail, the father has a birthplace of "The Flatts". (I shall raise a Spock-like eyebrow at that, as I am mildly sceptical about any burial record of a child recording the father's birthplace - maybe it's his residence? But put that to one side…)
If I try to put "The Flatts" into the FamilySearch Placename database, it gives me 4 places, of which the first is:
The Flatts, Monongalia, West Virginia, United States
Presumably this explains the Monongalia in the OP's original post.
However, when I try and search, as I say, I can't see anything other than "The Flatts" - no US data at all, indeed no higher level names at all after "The Flatts".
I've tried it using Search from Ellenor's profile, and Search / Records - in both cases using a browser running under Windows. Has @SarahSquire2 used something else? (Perfectly possible, of course!). Whatever it is, it looks like an inappropriate placename standardisation.
2
