As just another user, I have to say that I would hope that everyone realizes that the only thing the Merge Analysis view does is give a nice overview of what happened during that particular merge. But it gives absolutely no information or assessment as to whether any name, date, place, or source seen there is in any way correct at all or whether any other merge done was properly.

To actually evaluate the accuracy of a profile you do have to check the information currently on the profile and all the attached source as well as, usually, going through the entire change log.