The age given here makes him about five years or so too young to be "yours", and the place is different, but seventeen years is certainly long enough to have moved over one village. (And remarried, of course.) However, the fact that they've added the wife's maiden name as a disambiguating name for the husband implies that there were multiple Donics families in the parish, and more than one of them may have had men named Andrew.

1872
22. On the 27th (of May).
Deceased: András Donics Kraly, husband of Maria Kraly, Catholic religion
Residence: Krivostány 7.
male, age 57
Cause: died as consequence of a fall
Burial: Krivostány, on the 29th
Officiant: Rev. János Király assistant minister.

(I find it amusing that the parishioners use the Slovak form, Kraly, while the minister uses the Hungarian form, Király "king".)