Home› Ask a Question› General Questions

How do I report a problem with the Catalog location hierarchy?

tyams
tyams ✭✭✭
August 19 in General Questions

When browsing the FamilySearch Catalog by place, jurisdictions with identical names are not distinguished when they occur at the same level of the place hierarchy.

For example, under United States → Maryland, the “Places within Maryland” list contains a single entry labeled BALTIMORE. Although Maryland has both Baltimore County and the independent City of Baltimore, selecting BALTIMORE resolves to Baltimore City. There is no separate entry for Baltimore County:

image.png

As a result, Baltimore County cannot be selected through the hierarchical place browser, and the cities and other places nested beneath Baltimore County (and the catalog entries associated with those locations) cannot be reached this way. Effectively, this removes all Baltimore County locations from the browsable Maryland hierarchy and makes them undiscoverable, because they can only be found by searching specifically for Baltimore County:

image.png image.png

The same problem occurs with other identically named counties and independent cities, such as St. Louis County and St. Louis City, Missouri.

Suggested behavior:

Both jurisdictions should be separately selectable (for example, “Baltimore County” and “Baltimore City”), so that each branch of the place hierarchy remains accessible. Even a slightly jurisdictionally inaccurate workaround, such as nesting the independent cities within the counties of the same name for cataloging purposes, would be a functional improvement.

image.png 139.4K
image.png 96.2K
image.png 232.1K
Tagged:
  • Improvements
  • location error
  • using the catalogue
  • Correct catalog errors
1

Answers

  • Áine.ní.Donnghaile
    Áine.ní.Donnghaile ✭✭✭✭✭
    August 19

    @tyams A few months ago, I was advised that @m how is responsible for catalog issues. I don't know if that is still accurate.

    0
Clear
No Groups Found

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 47.5K Ask a Question
  • 7.6K Family Tree
  • 6.2K Search
  • 5.5K General Questions
  • 7K Get Involved
  • 1.2K Memories
  • 341 Other Languages
  • 82 Community News
  • Groups