I need help with a big family mess. Catherine Good L145-33B is my relative.

CaskJanell1

There is one source that shows she is married to John Powell and has one daughter Amanda E Powell born in 1866. Catherine Good was born to Christian Good and Elizabeth Shearer in 1841.

The other records that are attached to Catherine Good are a Husband John Miller and wife Catherine. There is no proof they are the same Catherine. There is no death records or divorce records. I was told by a FamilySearch Missionary not to detach any of the records because there is no proof. Janell Cask, [email removed for privacy] Thank you!

Áine.ní.Donnghaile

Profile L145-33B is Charle Dozin from Belgium.
https://www.familysearch.org/en/tree/person/details/L145-33B

Catherine Good's profile is L14S-33B
https://www.familysearch.org/en/tree/person/details/L14S-33B

We often see that the letter S and the number 5 are misread in profile identifiers. If you click on the profile, it will be automatically copied and can then be pasted to avoid the problem.

Catherine Good's profile currently has two sets of parents. That may be the first place to start working on the profiles.

A TREE

Still alot of additional cleaning needed for

https://www.familysearch.org/en/tree/person/sources/L14S-33B

However was able to separate sources where possible from

L14S-33B Catherine Good 1841–

For Catherine Teible, including removing the second set of parents and removing death date as belonged to Catherine Treible

As found proof in a death record also attached to find a grave of Catherine Treible

PZTW-NQ4 Catherine Treible 1837–1921 married to John Miller and daughter of Sarah Halterman and Charles Carl Treible

https://www.familysearch.org/en/tree/person/family/PZTW-NQ4