Home› Ask a Question› Search

court records Wissenkerke

JPBusman
JPBusman ✭
March 15 in Search

I have been going through the court records of Wissenkerke (Zeeland, NL) on your website [FamilySearch Catalog: Rechterlijke registers, 1653-1811] and for some mysterious reason it would seem only half the files have been unlocked. Therefore I assume there no possibly issue with publication rights.
For example the boederekeningen 1677-1732  and 1746-1778 are accessible, but the ones for 1723-1745 and 1779-1811 are blocked. That's quite random...I already spoke to representatives of the Zeeuws Archief in MIddelburg, who supported the creation of the microfilms at the time and they're unaware of any constraints in releasing the files as they're considered public records.Can you support unlocking all the files within this archive?

0

Answers

  • Áine.ní.Donnghaile
    Áine.ní.Donnghaile ✭✭✭✭✭
    March 15 edited March 15

    @SerraNola
    Could you please check the classification of this record set? I agree with the OP that it's odd that some records from the 18th century are not available.
    Thanks.

    image.png

    image.png 324.3K
    0
  • SerraNola
    SerraNola ✭✭✭✭✭
    March 17 edited May 5

    @JPBusman While it may seem excessive, the contents of wills are strictly private in the Netherlands and remain confidential even after death, accessible only to authorized heirs. I was informed that, based on legal review and guidance for the Netherlands, inheritance-related records, including wills, are subject to an indefinite restriction. In other words, regardless of whether the records are fifty or three hundred years old, if the description includes "will" or "estate," they will be restricted. All eight films in this collection with no access are classified this way.

    (Interestingly, some unrestricted items also fall into this category; if I request further review, it's likely that more will become inaccessible.)

    image.png

    image.png 917.1K
    2
  • Lars van Ravenzwaaij
    Lars van Ravenzwaaij ✭✭✭
    March 17 edited March 17

    @SerraNola Interesting point of view as I can actually acces old dutch wills and there content through dutch websites (as far as they are indexed). So this explanation is not quite satisfictory and the american Interpretation of the dutch guidelines and laws seems not to be completely correct.

    1
  • SerraNola
    SerraNola ✭✭✭✭✭
    March 17

    @Lars van Ravenzwaaij It's more likely not the American interpretation, but FamilySearch interpretation. The explanation came from FamilySearch Legal and whether I agree or not, I can only relay their decisions.

    2
  • JPBusman
    JPBusman ✭
    March 21

    @SerraNola that legal position is regrettably incorrect. All documents that are handed over to archival institutions are subject to the Dutch "Archiefwet", which stipulates when documents become public. That period for most documents is 75 years, for some documents like birth records 100 years. But there is most certainly no indefinite restriction on access to wills and testaments. I have no idea where anyone would have gotten that idea. And if you where to visit any of the website of the Dutch archival institutions you would in aquick glance be convinced that no institution applies the FamilySearch interpretation.
    The only exemption is for those testament that are explicitly classified as "verzegelde testamenten", i.e. sealed testaments which can only be accessed in the physical presence of an archivist. Those are archived separately from the ordinary testaments.

    This incorrect interpretation now used by FamilySearch is disastrous for access to wills and testaments, which had been long available on FamilSearch. So how can we overturn this?

    1
  • SerraNola
    SerraNola ✭✭✭✭✭
    March 25

    @JPBusman

    Your knowledge of Dutch documents is appreciated. I can only do my best to convey patron sentiment on decisions such as this. If there are any updates I will share them here.

    0
  • JPBusman
    JPBusman ✭
    April 10

    @SerraNola the question remains unanswered how we can address this problem with FamilySearch Legal. What's the path to contact them?
    I haven't seen any efforts from the moderators on this forum to do so.

    0
  • SerraNola
    SerraNola ✭✭✭✭✭
    April 10

    @JPBusman I'm struggling with making any progress. If you can prepare a more formal letter covering your earlier points, I'll get it to Contract and Compliance. You don’t need to use your full name.

    I was able to open up this film by having the record type changed from Wills to Court Records, but that won't work in every case.

    https://www.familysearch.org/en/records/images/search-results?imageGroupNumbers=9017626&page=1&pageSize=100

    2
  • JPBusman
    JPBusman ✭
    April 18 edited April 18

    Dear @SerraNola

    please find attached my letter to the Contract and Compliance team, in which outlined that "indefinite restriction" cannot legally be applied to Dutch archived documents.

    with kindest regards,

    (Name removed)

    e7882f0de16fde0108567d2f584c1c14-0.jpg

    e7882f0de16fde0108567d2f584c1c14-1.jpg

    e7882f0de16fde0108567d2f584c1c14-0.jpg 891.6K
    e7882f0de16fde0108567d2f584c1c14-1.jpg 450.1K
    0
  • sc woz
    sc woz ✭✭✭✭✭
    April 18

    @JPBusman

    Mod note: Community is a public online forum. For your privacy, your post was edited to remove a name that is not part of your username. Please see the Community Code of Conduct for more details. 

    0
  • JPBusman
    JPBusman ✭
    May 3

    @SerraNola it is taking months now and there hasn't been any movement in getting this resolved. I still haven't seen any response from FamilySearch on their (il)legal position to block Dutch public records. Why is there no effective process to adress this? Where can I raise a complaint on how this is being handled?

    0
  • SerraNola
    SerraNola ✭✭✭✭✭
    May 3

    @JPBusman I sent your letter (and two others) to higher management and would like to give it more time to get to the right hands. This is not a closed issue.

    You will have to address your last two questions to Admin. I'm just a lowly moderator. ☺️

    2
  • JPBusman
    JPBusman ✭
    October 7

    I am still waiting on a response from FamilySearch… the way this has been handled by management is disrespectful

    0
  • MandyShaw1
    MandyShaw1 ✭✭✭✭✭
    October 7

    @shecorwe this feels a bit like the recently discussed Sri Lanka issue, can you advise @JPBusman on best next steps to get a communication channel established that can resolve this issue please? Records Issues form? Thanks.

    0
  • betsy123
    betsy123 mod
    October 7

    @JPBusman We are sorry you have experienced some frustration with this question. This thread has now been flagged for moderation. Thank you for your patience.

    0
  • Alan E. Brown
    Alan E. Brown mod
    October 7

    @JPBusman Please accept our apologies for the delay in getting back to you. We should have done much better in responding.

    In April, your appeal was sent to the Contracts and Compliance team within the Legal department for review. They considered all the information, including the relevant contracts and laws and FamilySearch internal policies, which took some time. After this review, they concluded that the current access restrictions will remain in place for this record collection. I'm sure that is disappointing for you, but this is the final decision. We hope that you will be able to find other helpful records on FamilySearch or in other archives.

    Once again, we're sorry for taking so long, and we wish you well in your family history research.

    0
  • JPBusman
    JPBusman ✭
    October 7 edited October 7

    Hi Alan E. Brown,

    can you please share the details of the legal review that has been conducted by your Legal Department, because I do think it it relevant for FamilySearch users to understand which laws and/or policies FamilySearch applies to EU archival records. Especially, since it concerns records that have for long been public, and published on FamilySearch. The essential question is: What changed? Not EU-law. It will be of interest as well to Dutch archival institutions that may have deprioritised there own scanning efforts, because documents were until recently available on FamilySearch (after having kindly allowed FamilySearch to copy their collections on microfilm).

    The other item that hasn't been addressed is the "overzealousness" of blocking documents, as the restrictions even include generic indexes of court and notary records, records on guardianship, orphanages, etc. and are not limited to mere wills/testaments. So what is the exact scope of the "final decision"?

    Thanks + kind regards,

    1
  • shecorwe
    shecorwe mod
    October 7

    @JPBusman The exact details are not made known to us at the Community level. There are contractual obligations that we do not have access to.

    FamilySearch is committed to helping individuals discover and preserve their family history and strives to provide broad access to historical genealogical records. In some circumstances, however, access to certain collections may change due to contractual requirements, evolving privacy and other legal requirements, or
    technology updates. We understand it can be disappointing when a collection you rely on becomes unavailable, and we want to assure you that these adjustments reflect our continued commitment to protecting individual privacy and maintaining strong data-stewardship practices.

    Thank you for your understanding and continued support.

    0
  • JPBusman
    JPBusman ✭
    October 13

    Hi shecorwe,

    as a customer I am addressing as issue to FamilySearch, if I had a direct option to address this at the appropriate level I would. But as we're here at Community Level, I need you to obtain the information from "upstairs", because you have not been able to respond to a single item of concern in my previous message, neither the justification, nor the scope.

    It's a very very concerning lack of transparency

    0
  • MandyShaw1
    MandyShaw1 ✭✭✭✭✭
    October 13 edited October 13

    @JPBusman I share your concerns re transparency, but as FamilySearch's services are free of charge I am not sure that users like ourselves have any influence. The contracts are between FS and the relevant record custodians, so I would suggest that those are the people who can and should make sure that FS is exposing the information as agreed, and who can take the matter up with FS if there are mismatches.

    0
  • Tomlinsonkl
    Tomlinsonkl mod
    October 13

    We understand the desire for greater transparency. However, certain decisions, processes, contractual obligations, legal requirements, privacy considerations, and agreements with record custodians cannot be publicly disclosed. FamilySearch is required to operate within these restrictions and cannot share information beyond what is authorized. While we appreciate feedback and understand that not everyone will agree with these limitations, further speculation about internal agreements or legal matters is unlikely to result in additional information. This topic has been addressed to the extent possible. No additional information will be shared, further comments seeking details beyond those limitations are unlikely to receive a different response. Thank you for your understanding and cooperation.

    0
This discussion has been closed.
Clear
No Groups Found

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 48K Ask a Question
  • 7.7K Family Tree
  • 6.3K Search
  • 5.6K General Questions
  • 7K Get Involved
  • 1.2K Memories
  • 345 Other Languages
  • 84 Community News
  • Groups